Showing posts with label Tax collection. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tax collection. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 4, 2015

Government and Tax Collection: A Case Study Of The Adams Oshiomhole Government

BY DANIEL OSA-OGBEGIE, ESQ.


The first need of any modern government is to generate enough revenue, without which it would not survive another day. Thus taxation is by far the most significant source of revenue for the government. Nigerians regard payment of tax as a means whereby government raises revenue at the expense of their sweat.


Governor Oshiomhole
Governor Oshiomhole

It is good to note that no tax succeeds without the taxpayer’s co-operation. Here, we can ask some thought-provoking questions such as: what makes taxation such a difficult issue? Why do people feel cheated when it comes to tax? Is government making judicious use of taxpayer’s money?


To elicit voluntary compliance, the government should be more responsive to the welfare needs of the citizens. The Nigerian cum Edo tax system can effectively generate more revenue when the citizens have trust and confidence in the Government.


There is a need to enhance a positive tax culture; this can be done through the re-branding efforts of the ministry of information.  In most developed countries, tax payment is considered a moral and civic responsibility, thus tax avoidance is frowned upon. This implies that our leaders should demonstrate patriotism through leadership that is worthy of emulation by timely payment of their taxes and discharging other civic duties. Government cannot continue to shout down on the people to pay tax, the way Oshiomhole does, just because he could use the instrument of State to intimidate and pummel the people to submission.


The current determination of the Oshiomole government to implement the Land Use charge Law, and it’s defiant and autocratic move that had it “secure” a court order against 60 persons for the confiscation of the Property even when there was a pending matter before the Court show a government at war with its own people, unfortunately.


It is clear that only Local Government Councils can Constitutionally collect tenement rates, and tenement rate is part and parcel of the Land Use Charge Law.


For any Society to grow, the focus must be on building capacity, leadership,entrepreneurship and public institutions to create orderliness and empathetic governance. The Edo State Government uses touts and marauders to collect taxes from decent and hardworking members of the society, instead of devising the correct technology and any business innovation that would ensure orderly payment of tax.


I have always believed there was a point which the government and the people can both win; that point of intersection between the Government and the governed where they can both work together to create win/win situations most of the times. It seems to me that in Edo State, this may be far fetched!


The Adams Oshiomhole Government has not sufficiently shown to understand this point of intersection between the government and the people. The intersection goes far beyond the numerous platitudes and filibustering, masquerading as populism he constantly indulges in. It is simply about empathy and integrity.


The primary source of Government revenue in Nigeria has been crude oil for more than 45 years now. One would expect that a Government that suddenly intends to make taxes, rates, fees etc from its people the main source of its revenue, would first create the enabling environment for the people to be economically empowered by setting up incentives that would increase direct investments in the State, ensure security of lives and business, cut waste and leakages in government. The Edo Governor hs done none of these.


For sometime now, the Edo Governor Mr. Adams Oshiomhole has been frantically going round to source revenue in rather suspicious ways. Some of us have not been impressed. Infact I have been very annoyed as the Edo Governor’s tactics of raising internally generated revenue have been to put more and more tax burden on the Edo people even when Government has not first created that enabling business and social environment for the people to be economically empowered.

Furthermore, it is my contention that the people cannot be made to pay for the profligacy and financial recklessness of government.


To the carpenter, the solution to everything is a hammer. It is wrong for Edo State Governor to think the only way he can shore up the Government revenue is to impose more taxes, levies, fees and charges on the people. This for me, bothers on intellectual lassitude of those in Government. You don’t overburden a people already held down by Government inflicted economic depression by imposing more taxes, fees, rates, charges that they don’t have any means whatsoever to pay. You will call for insurrection when you do that. People cannot see you living in so much affluence courtesy of your position in Government, and agree to make sacrifices. You cannot expect the people to continue to subsidise you, then bear the brunt of your profligacy. If the Government is broke, instead of trying to milk the people, the Governor, Deputy, Commissioners, Advisers etc should cut their expenses, cut their salaries and allowances, cut down their fleet of official and private vehicles, cut down the Parties they organise, cut down the money they lavish on their girl friends and others, and most importantly, reduce the number of State Universities to one. No State Government can survive managing three Universities, and I don’t think there’s anywhere in the world this has ever happend. Thank you for reading.


Daniel Osa-Ogbegie is a Benin based Lawyer



Government and Tax Collection: A Case Study Of The Adams Oshiomhole Government

Monday, September 14, 2015

FG bars Tax consultants from collecting tax revenue

Tax consultants have been barred from assessing and collecting tax revenue on behalf of the Federal Government.


This clarification was given yesterday by the new Acting Chairman of the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) Mr. Babatunde Fowler in Abuja when he met with members of the Joint Tax Board (JTB).


Acting Chairman of the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS)

Acting Chairman of the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS)


Fowler admitted that consultants will be engaged by the FIRS to gather data only. He said the FIRS has under 1,000 staff in audit function. “So, you can imagine 1,000 staff trying to review or audit the books of 450,000 companies, it just won’t work, to improve the levels of transparency and accountability these consultants will only gather data, the law does not allow them to do assessment or collect revenue on behalf of government they’re just to assist our staff to collect data,’’ he said.


The FIRS he said will do the assessment with the States Board of Internal Revenues (SBIRs) and issue the demand notices for the tax due.


Some state members of the JTB had complained that many consultants come to make huge claims so that they can get huge commissions, but they don’t have the capacity to actually collect the huge revenue they claim to have collected in some states.”


On recent calls for an upward review of the Value Added Tax (VAT) collected by the federal government, Fowler noted that “it is the responsibility of the federal government and the federal ministry of finance to decide wether that (VAT) will change.


Fowler agreed that five per cent VAT charge was low when other countries that charge VAT both in West Africa and in Europe but those other countries have reached  the maximum level when it comes to paying taxes or public tax. “Those countries have 99 per cent tax compliance so I think we should first of all get there before we consider increasing VAT, when everyone is paying their taxes then we can look else where,” he said.


In order to build on the achievements of his predecessors, Fowler said he would reach out to SBIRs for collaboration stressing that “there are many stones left unturned as far as our current tax administration processes are concerned. For example, it is common knowledge that administration of VAT is greatly hindered by many factors, ranging from inadequate coverage of vatable persons to non-remittances of VAT deductions, tax revenue loss in this aspect can only be imagined.”


Speaking to reporters on how the FIRS will operate under his watch, Fowler said his strategy is going to change a bit.


He said: “Our objective is to have 99.9 per cent level of compliance meaning that everyone and corporate entities that are taxable are captured in the tax net and pay the appropriate tax.


“ FIRS will exchange information with states boards of internal revenue so that we have all the information on their own data base, we’ve given them ours already meaning that if there is any company that they don’t have in their data base they can capture such company so immediately we will have a growth in the number of tax payers at both the federal and state levels within one week.”


The FIRS Chairman said the agency has identified and located taxpayers through sharing and exchange of information as much as possible, addng that it will conduct joint audit exercises by FIRS and SBIRs; carry out joint tax enlightenment and enforcement exercises.



FG bars Tax consultants from collecting tax revenue